What is Cash's Fate? Healdsburg Animal Lovers in Anguish, Legal Battle

Cyrus restaurant's Douglas Keane files lawsuit against Healdsburg Animal Shelter; Shelter Exec Julie Seal has no plans to euthanize Cash, she says.


A dog named Cash is at the center of a major dispute involving high profile Healdsburg restaurateur and Julie Seal, exective director of

Keane, a volunteer at the shelter and chef-owner of top-rated restaurant, has filed a lawsuit against the shelter in connection with his wish to adopt Cash, an 110-pound, 3-year-old male Mastiff-pitbull mix.

A hearing on the lawsuit has been set for 3:30 p.m. tomorrow (Thursday, Dec. 1) at Sonoma County Superior Court satellite courtrooms at Empire College, 3035 Cleveland Ave, Santa Rosa.

According to Seal, Keane said he would place Cash, who Seal said was evaluated as "dog aggressive," in training with King's Kastle, an animal care facility with branches in Cloverdale and Windsor.

"Doug responded –- and I can produce the email –- stating that he was going to send the dog to King’s Kastle until he was safe to come home with him," Seal said in a letter to shelter board members over the Thanksgiving holiday weekend.

"I responded according to our adoption policies: his other dog would have to meet Cash and his wife would have to be present," she said.

"I also told him Colleen (Combs), the owner of King’s Kastle, was welcome to be there," Seal told the board members in her email. "His response was that I insulted him and I was making him 'jump through hoops.'"

Seal said she and shelter attorneys were in the process of drafting a liability waiver and insurance agreement for Keane to sign before they would allow Cash to be adopted out when Keane filed the lawsuit Tuesday, she said.

Neither Keane nor Keane's attorney, Rex Grady of the Edgar Law Firm in Santa Rosa, could be reached for comment Wednesday.

Seal says Cash has a history of aggression and received two recent independent trainers' evaluations of being aggressive.

She noted, however, that she has absolutely no plans to euthanize Cash, despite claims by some Healdsburg shelter volunteers in emails to Healdsburg Patch and on the Facebook page, Save A Dog Named Cash.

"What once was a wonderful place to watch animals get their new homes and a second chance has now become a high kill shelter," said one volunteer, who spoke on the condition of anonymity for fear of being shut out of the shelter. "Right now, the community of volunteers and local rescues, a hopeful new owner, and an attorney are coming together for one dog....'Cash.'

"A dedicated, professional trainer has been working with Cash for five months at Healdsburg Animal Shelter," the volunteer added, not giving the trainer's name. "He wanted to adopt him, but for no apparent reason, Julie Seal denied him the adoption and claimed the dog needs to be euthanized."

Seal, however, said Cash has charged and attackedHealdsburg Animal Control Officer Ryan Pelleriti.

"A male animal tech had to pull Cash off him; otherwise, he might have been hurt," Seal said.

On one occasion, Seal said she herself was attacked by Cash when she was standing next to a small dog.

"He lunged at me, or he might have been lunging at the small dog," she said.

Cash came to the shelter in August, after his family gave him up because they had a new baby, and "didn't trust him" not to hurt the baby, according to Seal.

Nonetheless, Keane's supporters claim the dog has no history of aggression.

"All of us love him! Cash has no bite report, no bad history, and he has been to Douglas's house!," another volunteer said. "The shelter let him paint for charity (with his paws) with Ellen Boone from the Paws for Love Foundation two weeks ago.

"All of us walk him and he knows 'sit,'  'down,' 'shake' and 'roll over.'" the volunteer said.
"He is beautiful and smart and Cash doesn't deserve to die!"

The volunteer said the shelter is giving false advertising about its "no-kill" status.

"I am upset that this shelter accepts donations from people in Healdsburg calling itself "no kill" when it's not," the volunteer said. "They've euthanized two dogs in the last two weeks and now they want to kill Cash."

Seal repeated that Cash was not slated for euthansia but that certain procedures had to be followed first to protect the community.

"As the executive director of the Healdsburg Animal Shelter, I do not feel it is morally or ethically right to adopt out this dog to a member of the community, even if that member of the community is a high-profile person engaged in an emotional appeal," Seal wrote to board members in the email, sent out before the lawsuit filing yesterday.

Seal said Wednesday she was not only concerned about what could happen with Cash and Keane's other dog -- or his wife -- but also what might occur if Keane, who volunteered as a dog-walker at the shelter and who also engaged in obedience training with the dogs as part of a requirement for a certificate as a trainer, would later adopt out Cash to another family and Cash would hurt a child.

"That could result in the failure of Healdsburg Animal Shelter," she said Wednesday. "We could be sued for millions."

Seal said two prior dogs at the shelter, Jayda and Sprite, were transferred to the Petaluma Animal Shelter for adoption after a Healdsburg shelter trainer deemed them both rehabilitated. Both dogs were returned to the Petaluma shelter after they attacked either family members or other animals in their adopted families, Seal said.

"I do not feel it is morally and ethically right to transfer this dog to another animal welfare organization who will then think he is rehabilitated and adopt him out into the community," she said in her email to the board.

As reported earlier in Healdsburg Patch, policy except if an animal is very sick or not able to be rehabilitated and is considered dangerous. The shelter is very reluctant to euthanize a dog or cat and has a extended process leading to that, with lots of checks and balances, according to earlier interviews with staff and board members.

"No one wants to see a dog euthanized," Seal said Wednesday. "But no one wants to be responsible for putting a dog in the community that then goes and hurts someone."

Maggie December 04, 2011 at 09:40 PM
well you say what you say, but she was just asked for help the same shelter who a few were quick to slander her months ago. After all you say about her and place blame, you still have the audacity to contact her and ask her to help. That took guts as she has enough unjustified media slander by 2 people to sue the pants off you and part of me wishes she would, but you do a good enough job digging your own grave, she is more committed to dog rescue than petty revenge and lies. and you still haven't explained what time bombs tick away in your shelter and are marketed on the internet for adoption. Who will you blame those dogs on, or will it take a tragedy for you to admit your failure. I'm glad you are done because this is about CASH. I just refuse to let you get away with lying about someone you envy and made you look bad while she was there, because she was so awesome!!! Haters move on, this story and battle is about love, lets appreciate the beauty of the human spirit and the courage it takes to stand up for an innocent animal. A lot of people are earning their wings this week.
Lisa Hadley December 04, 2011 at 10:59 PM
You are not the first and you will not be the last to experience this at the present day HAS. Animals are double adopted, sent out without all "disclosures" causing some to be returned, and even sent out without their vaccinations which the adopters had thought they had as stated on the website (hopefully all have been notified of this error). And if "someone" now says these are not factual I have a feeling there are enough of you Healdsburg that can refute that due to your own personal experiences. The bottom line is all this dialog is good as it opens the closet doors on what was and in many mays still is a wonderful shelter. But it does have it problems currently. All is not great because Julie is keeping a scorecard on animals she adopts from County...the numbers game is not the entire story of the Healdsburg Animal Shelter and you all are finally realizing that!
roosters1 December 04, 2011 at 11:01 PM
Ok, said I was done, but can't let someone take the blame for my words. WTF, you loone I'm not that person, shelters communicate amongs each other, just like rescues, duh. Her own reputation proceeds her, and not in a good way, all info in public records. I worked in shelters yes, volunteer in some now, so who ever you think I am your wrong, I would never ever ever ask her for help, envy, well most cult members think that way, so sure you go ahead and think that. That's a good follower, go fetch. Outa here!
Kitty December 05, 2011 at 06:45 AM
sounds like you are the one putting pins in the voodoo dolls, and drinking someone's kool aid, and needing counseling. Not to mention a little off topic. There are always people like you resistant to positive forward movement. You are sad rooster. Light a candle for Cash tonight. Volunteers are whispering to him, "Douglas is coming to get you, hang in there"
Nita Flores March 21, 2012 at 03:16 PM
Well said Rooster


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »